| Welcome Guest | Login |
Index
| Recent Threads
| Register
| Search
| Help
| 
| View Unanswered Threads
|
 |
Forums » List all forums » Forum: Game Design » Thread: Trophy Suggestion Thread |
|
Thread Status: Normal Total posts in this thread: 1394
|
[Add To My Favorites] [Watch this Thread] [Post new Thread] |
| Author |
|
|
Kaitysue
Joined: Sep 16, 2006 Posts: 509 Status: Offline |
Righto... but it isn't like I can go back again and get the little message as I hit that last point. /e is weird like that ---------------------------------------- Kait on Emerald Queen of Rebound Senior Officer of Dynamite Residue |
||
|
|
tarajayne
Joined: Sep 8, 2005 Posts: 1311 Status: Offline |
You would just get the message upon logging in if they were to create a new trophy. Silly to hold out for a trophy they may or may not ever create ;) ---------------------------------------- Bridalgirl I get around. |
||
|
|
Diver_Down
Joined: Jul 8, 2006 Posts: 367 Status: Offline |
Silly idea: A Can of Gnu, for being ordered to gun X number of times (possibly only when you are a jobber). ---------------------------------------- Hildebrand of Silent Fools on Sage Hilarion the labour alt on other doubloon oceans |
||
|
|
tanonev
Joined: Nov 18, 2006 Posts: 2361 Status: Offline |
Possible sailing trophies: Clear 5+ targets with a single chain Clear all targets on a board (min 5?) without making any regular 4+ of a kind clears (including in chains set off by clearing targets) Close-pack and then booch a board (hey, if they have Boots of Bilging, that means the trophies don't all have to relate to productive play :P) And the usual "count targets cleared" like crabs... Possible carp trophies: Nice Set Grain Bonus Masterpiece Use 2+ putties on a single hole Alternate between Masterpieces and Pig's Breakfasts for a full set of holes And the usual "count grain bonuses," "count masterpieces," etc. ---------------------------------------- Tanonev on all oceans; currently exploring Meridian. Puppetar by Tilinka |
||
|
warbuddy
 Joined: May 23, 2006 Posts: 9 Status: Offline |
True, but people already do that to get ultimate trpoheys. |
||
|
|
Jes_Roo
Joined: Oct 9, 2006 Posts: 99 Status: Offline |
I agree. We already have rewards for just sailing really well. The bilge trophies (i.e. crabs) don't have to be won with superior skill, although it's quicker to get them with higher skill. If the trophies in sailing were comparable to the ones for bilge, perhaps it should be for number of platforms cleared, or, for a little more skill, a certain number of platforms cleared as part of a 3 chain or higher? Just about anyone could get the "silver sailor" for 100 platforms (with 3 chain) with enough sailing, even if they are not very good sailors. Similarly for carp, as others have already suggested, 100 masterpieces would be doable for anyone (eventually) but much easier to accomplish with higher skill. ---------------------------------------- JesRoo First Mate of Eloquent & Princess of Cold Steel on Midnight Owner of Jesroo's Ironworking and Apothecary Stalls on Gaea
|
|||||
|
|
DreadedChris
|
Actually, they are harder to get with higher skill - people on the ultimate list take forever to get crab trophies because we bilge slower, with our pauses to think about bingo/donkey/vegas setups -- and because the timing works best with one clear ever 5-10 seconds, which is a long time comparitively. People with moderate skill get crab trophies best because they are doing small easy bingos and good doubles relatively quickly, moving a lot of blocks and so, a lot of crabs. I don't think any other puzzle has something that is easier for the moderately skilled player to get.... Still, I'd like to see counter-trophies for nice-set, grain-bonus, and masterpiece; for platforms cleared, and for bonus-blocks cleared. (bonus-blocks... there's a moderate-skill counter. I think. I'm not actually sure what ultimate sailing looks like, but those of us sub-ult end up clearing a lot of bonus blocks just to make our boards manageable. I imagine ults either ignore them or use them in a combo but don't make wasteful single-clears of them... maybe.) Guns already have a counter-trophy. ---------------------------------------- ~< The Dread Pirate Chris >~ |
|||
|
|
Jes_Roo
Joined: Oct 9, 2006 Posts: 99 Status: Offline |
Ah, good point. As a Ren/GM bilger, I simply rely on speed, which gets me more crabs. I didn't know leg/ults may actually bilge slower. ---------------------------------------- JesRoo First Mate of Eloquent & Princess of Cold Steel on Midnight Owner of Jesroo's Ironworking and Apothecary Stalls on Gaea
|
|||||
|
|
moooo666
Joined: Oct 4, 2005 Posts: 52 Status: Offline |
we need some trophies for gunners in cades~ its bad enough that they some times dont get paid for gunning (b-naver doen't fire enough, or they board sit). so what i was thinking is like chain shot (pic would be like one cb with a few chain links from it) for loading like 5000 cannons in blockades skull shot (pic would be like a flaming skull, this could also make a good trinket) for loading like 10000 cannons in blockades and have something like the tokens for number of guns loaded per segment, or round oaken token of gunning (like other oakens) 30 guns loaded per segment (so 150ish round) Seal of gunning (like others seals) 50 guns loaded per segment (250 per round) guns salute (name due like 20 gun salute, but they should be loaded by the time this is explained) (this would look more like two guns (simmilar to golden cannon but smaller) faceing oposing directions on a podium \ / and would say 'loaded' insead of incredible) token of gunning (same base with a normal cannon ball in it) for earning oaken like 5+ times steel marble (like other marble base with cannon ball) for earning a seal of gunning 8+ times finally, guns loaded (a gun (or two) sitting on a base of cannon balls, powder, and wadding~ maybe even a skull shot in there) for earning the guns salute like 10+ times i think this would help gunners feel less left out of cades and peoples thoughs? ---------------------------------------- Moocow of Hunter SO Black Watch (Collusion) born from the Sins of the Flesh an all around utterly evil pirate ** please note my opinions are my own ** |
||
|
|
kierra214
Joined: Jun 2, 2006 Posts: 874 Status: Offline |
It's not enough that you're rank can't go down in a blockade? I was under the impression that a lot of gunners were using blockades to boost their stat.
There already is a counter trophy for guns, why have a special one for blockades?
The oaken tokens and seals are for bonus pieces generated on the other duty puzzles. Gunning doesn't have blockade bonus pieces. Plus, these trophies would be less dependent on what the gunner does and more dependent on how many times the bnavver shoots. I think fixing the gunning blockade pay would be more useful to make gunners feel more included in blockades. All these suggestions are just giving gunners tons of trophies for doing the same thing: being good at gunning. Plus there's already tons of people wanting to gun. This would just cause more "can I gun, I'm really good" spam for the XOs. ---------------------------------------- Magrat SO of Polish War Fog Viridian |
|||||||
|
|
bluebudd
Joined: May 5, 2006 Posts: 4 Status: Offline |
what bout a trophy for earning a total of 1000 poe in the navy? and uhm, golden bucket for using up 1000 buckets just like in bildge? and like uhh golden fishy for earning 1000 fishes in blockades? |
||
|
|
TBPOTN7
Joined: Oct 28, 2006 Posts: 1415 Status: Offline |
for carpentry: filling 5000 holes > trophy filling 10000 holes > trophy filling 20000 holes > trophy keep yer hammer sparkling for a whole segment > golden hammer making four grain bonuses after eachother without pigs breakfasting > trophy for sails: filling 5000 patterns > trophy filling 10000 patterns > trophy filling 20000 patterns > trophy keep yer sail sparkling for a whole segment > golden sail |
||
|
RingRopes
 Joined: Sep 4, 2005 Posts: 651 Status: Offline |
How about a slice of pizza, for getting the No Pizza for you message? ---------------------------------------- Bangorian SO, Your Worst Nightmare Lord, Hardcore Explorers Sage |
||
|
|
MelonToaster
|
I think that some of the best trophies would for the "levels" of the rumble, swords and drinking. 10 swords 10 knockouts 10 cups sure, these aren't the most difficult, but neither is map and brew. They could be something like A+ swords A+ Rumble and A+ drinking (being as how you beat the teacher) Dnav should have 2 trpohies, one for memming one archepellagio, and another for memming the whole ocean. be like "old salt" and "sea master". |
||
|
|
BehindCurtai
Joined: May 25, 2004 Posts: 12589 Status: Offline |
How about a trophy for having 10 crabs on screen at once, or ten puffers at once, or ten jellies at once? (is 10 jellies even possible before it clears anymore?) ---------------------------------------- "We're trying to find the error bars on that number"
|
|||
|
|
RaggedAndy
Joined: Nov 24, 2005 Posts: 161 Status: Offline |
I have bootched Search-Fu, so I apologize if this has already been suggested: I find myself striving towards a certain accomplishment, and would like there to be a trophy when I finally achieve it: Sublime/Able in Gunning. I'm thinking a foot smashed by a cannonball. :P ---------------------------------------- RaggedAndy, Senior Officer in Mermaid's Typhoon on the Meridian Ocean, Vulfe, Officer in League of Shadows on Emerald, and various alts elsewhere. I'm a freaking old phart. Deal with it! |
||
|
|
AhoyLindsay
Joined: Sep 9, 2005 Posts: 3063 Status: Offline |
How about a trophy for having defeated all of the Brigand Kings? ---------------------------------------- Castawayjoe of the Midnight Ocean. To err is human, but to arr is pirate. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Catharsis on Cobalt and Malachite. |
||
|
|
ellopoppet
Joined: Apr 18, 2005 Posts: 4245 Status: Offline |
Or we could steer away from the only puzzle with fun looking trophies and maybe do it for getting 10 or more MP's at carp or Most boards cleared at sails. Given that they don't have jack atm. ---------------------------------------- ~Athens~ Hunter Want to know who makes my avatars? |
|||
|
|
RingRopes
Joined: Sep 4, 2005 Posts: 651 Status: Offline |
how about one for 1mil pillaged (on a boat not personally) then 10mil, 50mil & 100mil. ---------------------------------------- Bangorian SO, Your Worst Nightmare Lord, Hardcore Explorers Sage |
||
|
|
Artemis1207
Joined: Nov 23, 2006 Posts: 37 Status: Offline |
i have completed my 10th rumble but ya satisfaction might be better had i have a trophy!!! ---------------------------------------- Darknighter of Sage Ocean is thine name |
||
|
|
RA_Mako_AL
Joined: May 22, 2005 Posts: 86 Status: Offline |
I think it should be 15 or more MPs if you set it up for carpentry... I get almost constant incs/excels and I have yet to get past 13 MPs at once ---------------------------------------- | | | | | -->Yodaraal on the Cobalt and Midnight ocean!! -->Yodayar on the Cobalt ocean!! |
|||||
|
|
tookster9
|
There should definitely be a trophy for having memorised the ocean |
||
|
|
RA_Mako_AL
Joined: May 22, 2005 Posts: 86 Status: Offline |
well you get the globe which you can use in portraits but I wouldn't mind the same thing for an ocean completely memorized (globe trophy) ---------------------------------------- | | | | | -->Yodaraal on the Cobalt and Midnight ocean!! -->Yodayar on the Cobalt ocean!! |
|||
|
|
valio1992010
|
Hey, u know that when u play a lot of time a message appears? ''U've been playing a lot of time......''. Well, i think there should be a PP lover trophy which can be won by getting for example 50 times that message or something like that! What do u think? |
||
|
Tikikala
 Joined: May 25, 2007 Posts: 994 Status: Offline |
I was thinking of random trophies... Swordfighting Golden Stick -Awarded for WINNING 100 straight non-sea combat swordfightings....XD Rumbles Glistening Fish -Awarded for WINNING 100 rumbles before the item decay.... (cannot switch to other fishes) Golden Fish -Awarded for WINNING 100 straight rumbles (non-sea combat) there are my crazy input... thinking about that crab award in Bilging....XD ---------------------------------------- Tikikala in Viridian (main) , Sage, Hunter, Malachite, Crimson, and Opal. (But I don't speak German. @_@)
more quotes coming soon... |
|||
|
rockwalliby
 Joined: Sep 24, 2005 Posts: 31 Status: Offline |
i would like to propose an idea for two new trophy's the trophy's would be awarded to player who have gone out hunting brigands on the navy. the first trophy would be that they win 50 battles against the brigands this seems a lot but buy the time that they got this trophy they should have a very good idea on how to use a boat to it best but possible out come to win a battle. in which it would reflect on how they run there pillages when jobbing. plus it would show the captain that the said officer has achievement a certain level in bnav i know that we get the normal standing but at least you would know that they ahve done the hard yards to get this trophy the second trophy would be 100 wins on brigand with the navy this like the same above would help the pirates and would show a certain skill level plus then captain could put this into use for officer and fleet officer test if they want cos you can be told how to bnav and shown how to bnav but it isnt the same as you doing the bnav and learning the hard from be blown out of the water it still comes down to having your own style of bnav and what work best with your style of play |
||
|
BUCHANKO
 Joined: Jan 3, 2007 Posts: 145 Status: Offline |
Yeah... just wanted to tell that it is a very usefull suggestion. Coz captains would know of the members skill level.But i should be added like first trophy 50 battle second 150 third 400 and so on.Or may be even not such way but the idea is great. |
|||
|
|
RingRopes
Joined: Sep 4, 2005 Posts: 651 Status: Offline |
battling brigands with the navy can only teach you so much, not only are they all sloop vs sloop but you don't learn abouthunting for ships, ship management, stock, etc. More than that battling brigands (the mission) is incredibly boring ---------------------------------------- Bangorian SO, Your Worst Nightmare Lord, Hardcore Explorers Sage |
||
|
|
FallOutGirl
Joined: Jun 15, 2005 Posts: 4 Status: Offline |
I'm not sure if this has been suggested yet or not, but: There should be a trophy you get for say, every year you've been playing. That way you can tell how long a person has been playing the game for... I dunno I just think that would be cool :-) |
||
|
|
Rudebwoi
Joined: Feb 27, 2006 Posts: 515 Status: Offline |
With the latest release to include Floatilla's where we get the chance to kick some BK's Booty, and the fact that there are no trinkets awarded for this, I would like to see a selection of trophys introduced for:- Quantity of Green ships sunk ( posibly navver only for distinction and recognition of skill ) Quantity of overall Ships sunk ( ALL crew on ship included in this tally ) Floatillas defeated ( Flag Trophy, who says the flag cant have a trophy ) Its merely something thats just popped into my head so I thought I'd throw it to the comunity as I think most would like to see these trophys, it's just a case of a fair system of awarding them. ---------------------------------------- A Cuppa Tea makes everything better! |
||
|
|
[Show Printable Version of Thread] [Post new Thread] |
Powered by mvnForum
mvnForum copyright © 2002-2006 by MyVietnam.net