Puzzle Pirates Forums - Print Post -

Forums
» List all forums
» » Forum: Shore Leave
» » » Thread: ROMS: (DC)XV -- GAME OVER - TOWN WINS
» » » » Post: Re: ROMS: (DC)XV -- GAME ON

Print at Dec 4, 2020 9:38:46 AM

Posted by phaedra6 at May 26, 2012 8:03:55 AM

Re: ROMS: (DC)XV -- GAME ON
@Talisker
I went back to look for "evidence", and instead realized I kinda misunderstood this one:

Talisker quoting Randomact wrote:

That's a surprisingly salient point for so early in the game. There's really no good reason for asking in thread, if you're innocent.

I took this as jumping to the conclusion that she's a rogue, but all you are saying is that it does not really make sense to do such thing from an innocent point of view. That is a different.

On gut voting:
We keep arguing whether the gut feel is a good enough justification, while we cannot really call the vote in question a gut vote in the first place. It seems more like a random one being called a gut one. Some sort of behavior or action has to occur before you can have a gut reaction to it...
----------------------------------------
Disappear

Formerly and occasionally lurking around as Phaedra
SO of False Pretense

Bunnyspawn says, "Well, Dis, you have finally convinced me of your loss of innocence."
Bunnyspawn says, "I am frightened."